Poll | |
---|---|
Which one is better in your opinion | |
Photoshop | |
Gimp | |
I've another recommendations. | |
16 users have voted so far. |
MarioSunshine |
Posted on 04-18-12, 02:50 pm (rev. 1 by MarioSunshine on 04-18-12, 03:03 pm)
|
Fuzz Ball
KirbyFanatic64 (LOL) Karma: 1361 Posts: 348/950 Since: 11-13-11 |
Please!
I'm very hard to decide which image modifier I should use, between Photoshop and Gimp. So I make a survey about people's likes. Note that it's meant for all version, in another word, we're talking in overall. And it's OK for the price decision, why? See my second post. And beware, the main purpose of this survey is to get some opinions and suggestions between the two. Not show off your loving one and disdain another. Please participate, because I'm not good at all about these things. I'm new to it. Thank you very much. _________________________
Great games must be fun, not fancy.
Music Hacker needed! PM me if you wish!
|
Nadia |
Posted on 04-18-12, 02:52 pm
|
Axew
Karma: 673 Posts: 187/583 Since: 07-02-11 |
I'd say GIMP, because GIMP is free (both as in free beer and as in freedom).
|
Dirbaio |
Posted on 04-18-12, 02:54 pm
|
Super Mario
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Karma: 10020 Posts: 1633/4457 Since: 06-08-11 |
Gimp 100% for me
For 3 reasons: - It's free software - It works on Linux and Windows - It is as good as Photoshop (at least on what I use it for) I use it for making tilesets and BGs, more art for games, and for fixing photos sometimes And it's very powerful. I haven't used Photoshop a lot, bur as far as I can tell GIMP is awesome. Some say that it's difficult to learn to use, but it's not for me. So probably once you know how stuff works, you'll love GIMP |
MarioSunshine |
Posted on 04-18-12, 02:54 pm (rev. 1 by MarioSunshine on 04-18-12, 02:58 pm)
|
Fuzz Ball
KirbyFanatic64 (LOL) Karma: 1361 Posts: 349/950 Since: 11-13-11 |
Oh, that's true.
Free conquers all! I've forgot to tell ya, that I've both of them installed on my PC. So I can use them instantly if I want to. But I've to decide which. Posted by Dirbaio
Some say that it's difficult to learn to use, but it's not for me. So probably once you know how stuff works, you'll love GIMP I've tried to use it several times, mostly learning on my own. ( Yep, if something's gone wrong, just undo. ) And I find it's easy to learn and practice in basic techniques. Photoshop is tricky sometimes but it's quite powerful and well too. Hmmmm _________________________
Great games must be fun, not fancy.
Music Hacker needed! PM me if you wish!
|
LeWario |
Posted on 04-18-12, 02:55 pm
|
Banned for being a complete idiot.
Karma: 529 Posts: 813/987 Since: 07-09-11 |
I also go with GIMP.
It's faster, and much more easier to use that Photoshop. Photoshop has basically become bloatware in the latest versions (Another reason why Adobeo's going downhill). |
MarioSunshine |
Posted on 04-18-12, 03:00 pm
|
Fuzz Ball
KirbyFanatic64 (LOL) Karma: 1361 Posts: 350/950 Since: 11-13-11 |
Lol, Adobeo.
wow, I've never thought this thread has so much response. So impressive! Thank for all comments!!! _________________________
Great games must be fun, not fancy.
Music Hacker needed! PM me if you wish!
|
Freeze |
Posted on 04-18-12, 05:09 pm
|
Karma: 3752 Posts: 1075/2112 Since: 06-28-11 |
In my opinion Adobe makes the best programs. I tried Gimp once and never want to make my fingers dirty on it again. I think Photoshop is much more powerful (Probably I just didn't find the options in Gimp) and it seems much clearer to me.
Also I don't think Gimp is faster than Photoshop. Photoshop just works fine. I would only use Gimp if I ran Linux or if I didn't know how to crack Photoshop. I am of the same opinion with Premiere and different Video programs. I just like Premiere more. |
Piranhaplant |
Posted on 04-19-12, 02:00 am
|
Fuzzy
Full mod Karma: 1183 Posts: 398/785 Since: 06-28-11 |
I've tried both and I love GIMP, but I think Photoshop is better. Here are a some reasons I like Photoshop better:
I still recommend trying GIMP because it's free and is still a very powerful image editor, I just think Photoshop is better. |
unknown object |
Posted on 04-19-12, 08:52 am
|
Buzzy Beetle
I am UO, not UFO. Karma: 314 Posts: 110/393 Since: 08-28-11 |
I'd say gimp.
Why? Because it's free, and I think it's much friendlier. _________________________ NSMB6: Beta Testers Wanted!!! |
Nadia |
Posted on 04-19-12, 10:01 am
|
Axew
Karma: 673 Posts: 188/583 Since: 07-02-11 |
"Doesn't use a windowed interface"
Actually, there is an option in the GIMP 2.7 development builds for single-window mode. It's really nice. |
MarioSunshine |
Posted on 04-19-12, 12:17 pm
|
Fuzz Ball
KirbyFanatic64 (LOL) Karma: 1361 Posts: 352/950 Since: 11-13-11 |
Many people considered Gimp is better, hmm, mostly their main opinion is because it's free. BTW going through their specification is wanted to.
_________________________
Great games must be fun, not fancy.
Music Hacker needed! PM me if you wish!
|
Dirbaio |
Posted on 04-19-12, 12:49 pm
|
Super Mario
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Karma: 10020 Posts: 1635/4457 Since: 06-08-11 |
Posted by Nina "Doesn't use a windowed interface" Actually, there is an option in the GIMP 2.7 development builds for single-window mode. It's really nice. Oh really!? I'll have to try that out! |
Piranhaplant |
Posted on 04-19-12, 08:19 pm
|
Fuzzy
Full mod Karma: 1183 Posts: 399/785 Since: 06-28-11 |
Posted by Nina "Doesn't use a windowed interface" Actually, there is an option in the GIMP 2.7 development builds for single-window mode. It's really nice. Awesome! I'm definitely going to have to update. That was the main thing that bugged me about GIMP. |
LeWario |
Posted on 04-19-12, 10:41 pm
|
Banned for being a complete idiot.
Karma: 529 Posts: 815/987 Since: 07-09-11 |
For some things you have listed Piranhaplant, I would probably use a combination of tools (eg Blender for 3D).
And Gimp 2.8-RC1 is already out... lol |
Nadia |
Posted on 05-07-12, 02:15 pm
|
Axew
Karma: 673 Posts: 204/583 Since: 07-02-11 |
[slight bump]
GIMP 2.8 has been released with some new features and single-window mode. |
Dirbaio |
Posted on 05-07-12, 08:59 pm
|
Super Mario
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Karma: 10020 Posts: 1679/4457 Since: 06-08-11 |
Posted by Nina [slight bump] GIMP 2.8 has been released with some new features and single-window mode. W00T!! * Dirbaio downloads it right now... |
Piranhaplant |
Posted on 05-07-12, 10:14 pm
|
Fuzzy
Full mod Karma: 1183 Posts: 403/785 Since: 06-28-11 |
Yay! Single-window mode is so awesome . It also has layer groups (finally), better text editing, and comes with python-fu!
|
MarioSunshine |
Posted on 05-09-12, 04:46 am
|
Fuzz Ball
KirbyFanatic64 (LOL) Karma: 1361 Posts: 380/950 Since: 11-13-11 |
Excuse me, who has got another recommendation? (Which's neither Photoshop nor Gimp )
LOL I think Gimp would be the winner. _________________________
Great games must be fun, not fancy.
Music Hacker needed! PM me if you wish!
|
acmfan |
Posted on 05-09-12, 07:24 am
|
Paragoomba
Karma: 42 Posts: 20/66 Since: 04-28-12 |
Paint.net is the best!
_________________________ NSMB-Hard Edition, I'm working on it! |
Nadia |
Posted on 05-09-12, 12:39 pm
|
Axew
Karma: 673 Posts: 207/583 Since: 07-02-11 |
Posted by acmfan Paint.net is the best! Depends. If you want to do more advanced things, you have to use something like GIMP. |