It seems everyone has dozens of comments of people wishing them happy birthday on their profiles. I mean, I'm guilty of telling people i don't know happy birthday too, but like, doesn't anyone else find this strange and a bit spammy? I know you can delete comments if you don't like them, but there's people haven't logged on in years who have pages dedicated to being told "happy birthday". I don't know. I feel like the NSMBHD birthday culture is the result of people's names being shown to everybody on every page when it's their birthday. I would say they should get rid of it, but it's been on the site so long that nothing could change it.

It’s not strange or spammy, and you have a choice to show your birthday. And what other purpose would the comment page serve than saying “You suck” or “You’re cool”. NSMBHD is barely used anymore anyways. This place is more of an archive now.

(Edit): forgot you were already on the discord lol






Cool website

But you gotta admit it's pretty weird never seeing these people online and suddenly on your birthday there they are. But I don't know, these are the only birthday wishes I get, irl no one wishes me happy bday to be honest

Fair point. DoB isn't required and it's something you opt into, but I disagree with the notion that comment pages on this site barely have a purpose outside of that; I mean, I've had  BL4ZED just ask me what's up and ask me about the hack I was making. The Discord is definitely better for that type of stuff, but I don't think this place is completely obsolete because people are still making NSMB hacks and are publishing them here, and not GameBanana or Romhacking.net. Despite being barely alive, somehow, this place has managed to survive and not be centralized/consolidated. You could say it's because this place has been here first, but a lot of forums were there first and got absorbed into Reddit. I think there's something special to this place still.